Wednesday, April 6, 2022

Gordon Clark: Review of “Perspectives on 19th and 20th Century Protestant Theology” by Paul Tillich (The Presbyterian Journal)

1967. Review of “Perspectives on 19th and 20th Century Protestant Theology” by Paul Tillich. The Presbyterian Journal. XXVI

PERSPECTIVES ON 19TH AND 20TH CENTURY PROTESTANT THEOLOGY, by Paul Tillich. Harper & Row, New York, N. Y. 252 pp. $5.95. Reviewed by Dr. Gordon H. Clark, professor of philosophy, Butler University, Indianapolis, Ind. 

This book is published from tape recordings of lectures Tillich gave in 1963 in Chicago. The contents are impressionistic pictures of a number of recent philosophers and their themes. 

This procedure, which is allowable to a thinker in his mature years, enables Tillich to reflect on his view of faith and the nature of religion. He notes that rationalism and mysticism are akin, not antithetical. The particular state of theology in America is, in one respect, the result of this nation's never going through a period of Romanticism — Goethe contributed so much to German theology. 

Some of the impressions are a little startling. One wonders whether secularism's reluctance to face death is due to the Jesuits' support of bourgeois capitalism. Orthodox Protestants will be surprised to hear, even though they are familiar with Tillich's bias, that they believe God dictated the Bible as a boss dictates a letter to a stenographer at a typewriter; and that they also believe that the King James version is the very Word of God. 

Naturally we must not expect liberal scholars to study very carefully the religion they attack.

No comments: