Tuesday, April 5, 2022

Gordon Clark: Review of "Faith and Reason," by James Deotis Roberts (The Presbyterian Journal)

1962. Review of "Faith and Reason," by James Deotis Roberts. The Presbyterian Journal. XXI.

FAITH AND REASON, by James Deotis Roberts. The Christopher Publ. House, Boston. 98 pp. $3.00. 

The thesis of this overpriced book is that Bergson to a small degree and William James to a greater degree made some progress toward the more satisfactory faith of Pascal. Although the two were not Christians, their intentions were good, and all three were in basic agreement (pp. 62, 73). 

The author seems to depend too heavily on secondary material, especially the work of G. M. Patrick and Dorothy Eastwood. One is also left to wonder whether Pascal's wager works with the Koran as well as with the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Detailed argument on several such subjects would have been a great help to the reader. 

- Gordon H. Clark, Ph.D. 
Indianapolis, Ind.

No comments: