Showing posts with label John Robbins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Robbins. Show all posts

Thursday, December 26, 2024

Clark's Critics

At this point, it almost goes without saying that I enjoy interacting with critics of Clark (link, link, link, link, link, and so on). I myself critique Clark here and there, but there are better and (usually) worse attempts. It would be impossible to respond to every critic, and I don't feel any sort of compulsion to interact with everyone - especially not random people on the internet. But in time, I do hope to have a decent collection of responses to critics who were worth engaging.

I've mostly dealt with contemporary authors. It would take much more investment of time than I have at present to comb through all of Van Til, Bahnsen, Frame, and others' work who may not be as well known now but were during, say, the 1940s OPC controversy (e.g. Klooster, Kuschke, Stonehouse). It would also be reinventing the wheel to go over ground that has been sufficiently covered by others. 

As an example, John Robbins responses to Hakkenburg, Hart, Muether, and Dennison are mostly correct (link), if not comprehensive and mild-mannered. Robbins also is more willing to speculate when matters call for historical exactness - though, to be fair, so are those whom he is responding to. Hart and Muether, for example, write,
Clark and his supporters wanted the OPC to join forces with other conservatives in the United States. The basis for this union was not the explicitly Reformed views of the Westminster faculty but rather the broad mission of opposing modernism and banding together for effective outreach. In 1943 Clark went so far as to invite all foes of liberalism to join the OPC. Ministers in the OPC who sided with Clark also hoped the church would become more evangelical than Reformed... 

Despite these criticisms of the OPC, the church, by remaining outside the new evangelical movement and by joining an international association of Reformed churches, rejected Clark’s vision for the denomination. The OPC was to be a distinctly Reformed denomination as defined by the Westminster Standards, not “evangelical” or “conservative” as defined by the new evangelical movement...
Those who left the OPC with Clark were saddened by the church’s vision. They believed that the church had been founded to oppose “soul-destroying Modernism” and was now moving away from its original vision. But as we have already seen, the forming of the OPC involved far more than fundamentalist opposition to modernism. Machen was dedicated to maintaining and preserving a Reformed testimony (link).
Robbins refutes this. He also refutes Michael Hakkenburg's assertion that "A Reformed theology, although important to this group [the "Clark group"] was not crucial in the battle against modernism" (Pressing Toward the Mark, pg. 337). 

But it doesn't hurt to add historical facts that support Robbins' case. A part of the reason I am transcribing Clark material just is to help set the record straight as to what Clark really believed. See the "MINORITY REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE ON THE AMERICAN COUNCIL OF CHRISTIAN CHURCHES," which Clark signed off on with another minister (link). Particularly:
We do not believe that it is necessary to argue against religious cooperation with unbelievers, those who deny the fundamentals of the Christian faith, or against organic union with Christian bodies which we believe are less pure in doctrine. On these two points there is in our denomination general agreement. We believe also that there is general agreement to the proposition that there must be cooperation with other truly Christian bodies whom we believe are less pure insofar as such cooperation does not compromise and impair what we believe to be true...

It is possible to make a common testimony to the catholic doctrine common to the whole confessing Church embraced in the great ecumenical creeds and at the same time maintain our distinctive reformed witness. This is a council of Churches for common action against the enemies of God, to wit, Modernism, Romanism, Communism, and any other ism which denies or compromises the truthfulness of the above doctrines. It takes common action in behalf of historic Christianity. It is not a union of Churches. It is not saying or implying that we consider that our distinctive reformed witness is unimportant any more than others in the Council think that their arminianism, immersion or ritual is unimportant. It is a Council in which Bible-believing Presbyterians, Methodists, Baptists and Independents remain such with all their hearts and yet stand together as citizens of the Kingdom of God in conflict with the Kingdom of Satan. It is a Council which is pledged not to do work which is generally accepted as being in the ecclesiastical sphere. It is pledged to aid the constituent denominations in their distinctive witness...

Our world and life view demands that our isolationism be ended. Christian love demands that we aid our brethren who are undergoing so much for us. We need to remember that:

1. Affiliation with the American Council will not undermine our distinctive reformed witness, on the contrary it will obtain a greater hearing for that witness.

2. It is impossible to delegate ecclesiastical authority to any Council. Ministers are always subject to the discipline of their respective denominations or churches. Committees of the denominations must report to their denominations. Denominations can drop out of the Council or repudiate its decisions at any time.

Now, one can agree or disagree with Clark that cooperation is possible without compromising one's Reformed witness, but this does show that Hart and Muether - who really ought to know better - slandered Clark in suggesting that he himself "hoped the church would become more evangelical than Reformed." Would these men have said the same about Stonehouse, a complainant who - a mere two years after the above report - according to Charles Dennison, "defended OP involvement in the fundamentalist International Council of Christian Churches" (History for a Pilgrim People, pg. 172)? No, Hart and Muether reckon Stonehouse among other members of the "wise leadership" in the OPC, and no mention (let alone insinuation) is given to his evangelicalism. Robbins' vehemence is rather warranted in this case.

It appears Hart and Muether are more or less repeating Van Til (link, minute 13:30-23:30). For example, see his following comment (minute mark 23:02):

...you are not to continue doing what is being done by Dr. Carnell, by Dr. Clark, by Dr. Buswell, and good Christian people who are the "new evangelicals." They are not answering the neo-orthodox. They want to keep in touch with the neo-orthodox, because that's the movement going in theology, and with existentialism in philosophy.

Now, at the end of the lecture, Van Til says Clark is 65. Therefore, the lecture must have been given in 1967 or 1968. This makes sense, since Van Til references a book by Jurgen Moltmann written in 1967 at the very beginning of the lecture. 

What that implies, though, is more slander. I really do try to be charitable - and I will continue to do so to the best of my ability - but for Van Til to include Clark among those "not answering the neo-orthodox" but rather wanting "to keep in touch with them" is unacceptable for a man in a position to know better. 

Can we believe Van Til really not aware of Clark's book dedicated to refuting Barth published 5 years earlier? Can we believe he was not aware of any articles in which Clark attacked neo-orthodoxy repeatedly and publicly, some as early as 1954 (select examples: link, link, link)? By my count, there more than a dozen published articles - did Van Til read none of these? Then what did he read that evidences his claims about Clark and neo-orthodoxy? He doesn't say, and neither to Hart and Muether state the bases for their claims. 

In agreement with Van Til, Clark even charges Carnell with neo-orthodoxy in a letter to Carl Henry on 1/30/1960 (link). But Clark also claims neo-orthodoxy infiltrated Van Til's own thought as early as a 1951 letter (link):

In addition to this group of changes you also mention the reference to Dr. Van Til. So far as the argument is concerned, this section could be deleted, for Dr. Van Til is by no means so important a figure as Brunner. However, he is an excellent example of how neo-orthodoxy has permeated contemporary thinking. Dr. Van Til “adores paradox,” he holds that man’s mind is incapable of knowing any truth, that the Bible from cover to cover is not the truth, and that theological formulations, creeds, and so on are only “pointers” to something unknowable. The dependence on Brunner, even the wording, makes Dr. Van Til an admirable example.

Compare this charge to Van Til's reference to paradox in the same 1967 lecture (minute mark 21:59):

God is God, and his all-comprehensive control and our sense of responsibility will always appear to us apparently contradictory - not really, it isn't. But we have to believe that it isn't.

Regarding this statement: we can acknowledge that Van Til believed Christianity to be consistent while simultaneously denying that we can understand said consistency. The real question is the apologetic double standard this seems to entail - that unbelievers could shrug as Van Til lodges refutations and respond that such as merely examples of paradoxes, not real contradictions. Van Til may even ironically respond that his reference to the necessity of apparent contradictions as compatible with his consistent worldview may itself appear contradictory (yet not be) when compared with an unbeliever who likewise cites the necessity of apparent contradictions as compatible with their consistent worldviews. But insofar as apologetics is a practical enterprise, there is a real challenge here. 

If an unbeliever charges Van Til as believing a contradiction (God's sovereignty along with human responsibility), if all Van Til can do is say, "Well, it does seem contradictory but really isn't - I can't explain why, though, I just believe it," he is inhibiting the work of the Spirit. The Spirit works through ordinary people, but only insofar as we are communicating truth. Van Til's position on the necessity of apparent contradictions isn't truthful and can't be supported from Scripture. 

Returning to the more important conclusion that should be drawn from the above: a concerning trend among OPC theologians (and even historians) who do not agree with Clark's position in the 1940s debate is a tendency to make historically inaccurate statements about what Clark's positions even are. I won't speculate on the reasons, but it is an unavoidable fact that there are false narratives about Clark's beliefs.

And it really is a shame. Van Til interacts with Clark in other ways in his lecture, some of which are not only deserving of a response but might also touch a sensitive spot in Clark's thought! Very few who know what Clark did think, though, will be inclined to give further hearing to Van Til after his listening to obvious misrepresentations. 

I will give Van Til further hearing shortly, but as a side note to the above, there is a case to be made for the true sort of alliance for which Clark sought. Opponents of Clark should instead engage something like the following, which comes from Gary North's Crossed Fingers and virtually implies Clark's view was the same as Machen's (contrary again to the the narrative of Hart of Muether that it was the post-1939 WTS faculty who maintained and preserved the same Reformed testimony as Machen):

The Princetonians were not ecumenists. They did not view the near-term future as a period of legitimate unity among evangelical churches. There can be unity among Christians, they taught, especially in the battle against modernism, but they resisted any alteration of the Confession, which meant that they could not accept Church unity in their day. The other churches would have to adopt the Confession in order for the Princetonians to accept ecclesiastical ecumenism: Church union as distinguished from temporary alliances.

...numerous critics of Machen, in his day and ever since, have argued that his opposition to this union was inconsistent with his later cooperation with fundamentalists and other conservative evangelical organizations. This criticism is misleading. The issue in 1920 was not the legitimacy of alliances, which are permitted by the Bible (Gen. 14:13); the issue was the theological basis of Church covenants. Alliances are not covenants. Alliances are not created by means of a self-maledictory (negative sanctions-invoking) oath before God.(238) Machen never spelled out this distinction by means of covenantal language, for he rarely used covenantal language, but his hostility to Church union was based on his understanding that the fundamental issue was covenant law, not cooperation as such.

More could be said, of course. One could discuss whether it is wrong-headed to protest abortion or feminism with Reformed Baptists or Lutherans, the relevance of the WTS faculty and OPC members who did not want to submit to denominational oversight (Doug Douma touches on this here), whether it's possible that some's acceptance of a Radical Two Kingdoms view has encouraged OPC isolationism, etc. But I think enough has been said on the "new evangelicalism" for this post.

In the spirit of a fair hearing, I now want to interact with the rest of Van Til's lecture. A fair hearing is not only often missing in contemporary engagements in which the thought of one man is typically evaluated through the lens of the other, it's something that was sometimes missed by Clark and Van Til themselves in each's expositions of the other's views. I'm not suggesting I'm unbiased. But I will aim to actually show where both Clark and Van Til were right or wrong. At this stage in history, it really is not enough to merely say that both Van Til and Clark made mistakes. We should be acknowledging what those mistakes were as well as whether these were pointed out to each other.

At any rate, the first meaningful statement involving Clark comes at minute mark 14:36:

Well, there is no other unless they are willing to make use of their own position which is, in Clark's case, the Reformed faith. Now if you are willing, actually, to start with the Christian position in its full expression, in the Reformed confessions, then the only thing you must do and can do is to say, "Well, look, there is no common ground between you and us - to wit, on which we agree as to interpretation. There is a common ground in that you are a creature of God as I am a creature of God. We're both made in the image of God. You don't believe that though, so that's not how you interpret man."

There has been much recent debate about what Van Til meant by "common ground." It doesn't seem that Van Til could be much clearer: the common ground is solely ontological. Not epistemic, not psychological. 

As an example, Dr. Keith Mathison recently published Toward a Reformed Apologetics: A Critique of the Thought of Cornelius Van Til. After a youtube discussion between he and James Anderson, I engaged with many admirers of Van Til that Mathison has it all wrong - Van Til taught that unbelievers could believe truth, just not justifiably so.

But is this not completely ruled out by what Van Til says? There is nothing on which we agree as to interpretation. This actually goes back to the 1940s debate. I've spoken on this before, but permit me to cite a fellow complainant of Van Til (against Clark) who, in the presence of Van Til himself and without any correction, said the following (link):

...according to Mr. Kuschke, "Dr. Clark regards man's intellect as occupying such high rank that the understanding of the natural man can grasp the meaning of the words 'Christ died for sinners' 'with the same ease' as the born-again man. If that is the case, the understanding does not need to undergo renewal like the rest of the human personality." Mr. Kuschke quoted and discussed at length the statement of the proposed answer that "regeneration, in spite of the theory of the Complaint, is not a change in the understanding of these words [Christ died for sinners]." He pointed out that the Bible teaches that all of man's faculties are corrupted by sin, and that every imagination of the thoughts of man's heart is only evil continually. "If regeneration did not change our understanding of the words 'Christ died for sinners,' " he declared, "then we would never be saved!"

...The supporters of Dr. Clark's theology made valiant effort to defend the statement of the answer that "regeneration... is not a change in the understanding of these words [Christ died for sinners]." Mr. Kuschke, on the other hand, defended the position of the complaint and pointed out that, when content is injected into the sentence, the unregenerate man must invariably inject the wrong content and the regenerate man the true content.

Forget the idea that unbelievers can have true beliefs - what is being affirmed (against Clark protestations) is that unbelievers can't even understand truth. Unbelievers never interpret statements as believers do - i.e. correctly - due to their anti-Christian positions. Do you say you accept the authority of the Bible but believe that we are justified by faith and works? Then you don't really believe we are made in the image of God. You might say you believe it, but your anti-Christian position means your interpretation must be different. If I can attempt an illustration on Van Til's behalf, it would be like if a Nestorian claimed to accept the council of Ephesus. They could only claim such by implicitly or explicitly twisting the meaning of the words of said council.

When I mentioned some of this to Dr. Mathison himself - whose book has recently been delivered as a present and which I plan to read soon - he agreed with my understanding (post 21 here). Dr. Mathison also posted fantastic summaries of and evidences for his position: see posts 17 (the last 4 big paragraphs in particular) and 31-32. There isn't much I need to say by way of refutation of Van Til's position on "common ground." Clark dealt with it long ago, also pointing out, like Dr. Mathison, that Van Til seemed to contradict himself (link):

One important reason for maintaining the distinction between consistent systems and inconsistent persons is that unregenerate persons are thereby permitted to have at least some knowledge. Since the Scriptures base responsibility on knowledge, and since Romans 1:32 assigns to the wicked an amount of moral knowledge sufficient to make them guilty of sin, the evangelical must frame a theory by which this knowledge is shown to be possible. Were a man totally ignorant, he could not be guilty of sin.

Now, strange as it may seem, although Van Til's statements, quoted above, inexorably imply that the unregenerate are totally ignorant, Van Til makes some contradictory remarks.
Clark used "knowledge" in a range of ways. I suspect the definition of "knowledge" he means here is "true belief" (cf. Karl Barth's Theological Method). In other contexts, Clark refutes related theses to Van Til's position on "common ground" (see the subsection "A Subsequent Paper" here). I connect some dots here.

Let's pivot focus: does Clark start with "the Reformed faith... in its full expression, the Reformed confessions"? Well we could nitpick here and discuss sola scriptura, the fallibility of confessions (which Westminster Confession did Van Til allude to, for example?), and so forth, but loosely speaking, Clark would have affirmed he did so. Van Til objects (minute mark 16:56):
You must not do what Dr. Clark does. He believes this position theologically. And then when he goes to defend it, he joins with all other historical Protestant defenders - that is so far as the Butler type of analogy is concerned. "And look," he says, "our position is more logical. And I'll show you that it's more logical, or that it's absolutely logical." But at the at the end of this little article to which I return in the Moody Press publication, "Can I Trust My Bible?" there he says, "but not absolutely because it may all depend." Well, don't you see, that is making possibility - abstract possibility - back of God. Here, God is the source of possibility. Nothing can be or happen except that that which is within and in accordance with the plan of God. Here, he is willing to take all this and to say, "the more logical and more acceptable hypothesis." Now, that's just exactly what Satan wanted man in paradise to do: not to accept this on authority...

Then, at minute mark 19:17 (after praising Clark's determinism and belief in the infallibility of the Bible, Van Til says:

But then why does he turn right around and join all of the historic Arminians, defenders of the Christian faith, in appealing to autonomous man and say, "Look, you've got a hypothesis and we've got a hypothesis. Ours is better than you." Now, why is ours better? Because it's more according to the law of logic. I mean to put law of contradiction. Well, the point is that what we should do - and what Clark as a Calvinist theologian virtually does - is to say that the law of contradiction cannot work in a chance universe. The difference between our position and that of others is not ours it is more logical or less logical. Faith is not a leap in the dark. But neither is faith, don't you see, something that is in accordance with the law of contradiction. The issue is not whether it is more or less in accordance with the law of contradiction. The point is that the law of contradiction cannot operate in a vacuum.

This is quite a lot to cover here. I'll skip the reference to "the Butler type of analogy." Van Til doesn't explain his meaning in this lecture. 

Let's start by agreeing with Van Til that we can't start with abstract possibility or hypotheses. If we did, there would be no epistemically helpful criterion for evaluation of said hypotheses (link), so the result would be skepticism. Somewhere in the lecture, Van Til mentions that hypotheses can only function within the system of truth. This is very good, and it indirectly supports Van Til's contention that a transcendental argument for Christianity can be made, involving logic no less (cf. the end of this link; full disclosure, I seem to have misunderstood Van Til here). We can further refine this by noting said argument will not increase our epistemic justification in what we already know apart from inference, but the argument itself can still be useful (link).

With that in mind, Van Til is talking about Clark's article, "How May I Know the Bible is Inspired?" (link). But nowhere in that article does Clark use the word "hypothesis." A charitable interpretation of Van Til would be that he is speaking conceptually based on other evidence. His only evidence, to my understanding, that Clark affirms that whether or not Christianity is true "may all depend" is his reference to what Clark says here: 

The more consistent unbelief is, the less can agreement be obtained. So long as the unbeliever is inconsistent, we can force him to make a choice. If he inconsistently admires Jesus Christ or values the Bible, while at the same time he denies plenary and verbal inspiration, we can by logic insist that he accept both – or neither. But we cannot by logic prevent him from choosing neither and denying a common premise. It follows that in logical theory there is no proposition on which a consistent believer and a consistent unbeliever can agree. Therefore the doctrine of inspiration, like every other Christian doctrine, cannot be demonstrated to the satisfaction of a clear-thinking unbeliever.
If, nonetheless, it can be shown that the Bible – in spite of having been written by more than thirty-five authors over a period of fifteen hundred years – is logically consistent, then the unbeliever would have to regard it as a most remarkable accident. It seems more likely that a single superintending mind could produce this result than that it just happened accidentally. Logical consistency, therefore, is evidence of inspiration; but it is not demonstration. Strange accidents do indeed occur, and no proof is forthcoming that the Bible is not such an accident. Unlikely perhaps, but still possible.

Again, this too contains a lot to unpack. There is a fundamental question here: when Clark is speaking of logic, is he speaking of it as the criterion for knowledge to which we must subject Scripture itself? This cannot be (see the following quotes). If Van Til is presupposing that Clark thinks the proof of the Christian position comes by making it answer to the law of contradiction (cf. minute mark 16:13-16:24), this is contrary to Clark's thought:

One who believes in the unity of truth may still believe that the false system entails contradictions; but to prove this is the work of omniscience. (Historiography: Secular and Religious, 1971, pg. 370) 

Undoubtedly I hold that truth is a consistent system of propositions. Most people would be willing to admit that two truths cannot be contradictories; and I would like to add that the complex of all truths cannot be a mere aggregate of unrelated assertions. Since God is rational, I do not see how any item of his knowledge can be unrelated to the rest. Weaver makes no comment on this fundamental characteristic of divine truth.

Rather, he questions whether this characteristic is of practical value, and whether it must be supplemented in some way. It is most strange that Weaver here says, “I must agree with Carnell,” as if he had convicted me of disagreeing with Carnell by providing no supplementation whatever. Now, I may disagree with the last named gentleman on many points, but since it is abundantly clear that I “supplement” consistency by an appeal to the Scripture for the determination of particular truths, it is most strange that Weaver ignores my supplementation. (Clark and His Critics, 2009, pg. 290)

In view of this pragmatic dealing with history, its positivistic denial of universal law, of metaphysics, of supernatural interpretation, it may be permitted by way of anticipation to suggest the conclusion that, instead of beginning with facts and later discovering God, unless a thinker begins with God, he can never end with God, or get the facts either. (A Christian Philosophy of Education, 1988, pg. 31)
Perhaps Van Til would say Clark was inconsistent. That's possible, but we should first consider if any alleged tension can be resolved in a different way. Some space for charity is needed for Clark as well as Van Til. When I read Mathison's book, I will certainly try to extend Van Til the same courtesy. 

Another reason to reject that Clark thinks the proof of the Christian position comes by making it answer to the law of contradiction is that the "How May I Know the Bible is Inspired?" quote above blatantly rejects that Christianity can be demonstrated by logical consistency. Van Til seems to interpret Clark as back peddling: Clark set out to prove Christianity by logic, couldn't do so, and, therefore, Clark's hand is forced and he must admit that Christianity is not absolutely logical: it "may all depend," and "abstract possibility" is "back of God." I'll return to this in a moment.

Let's first give Clark some humbling: it must be admitted that there is at least one particularly concerning Clark quote, found in a 1981 correspondence with John Robbins (link, see below), which does entirely seem to justify Van Til's accusation. Robbins is spot-on, and I find Clark's reply to be outright indefensible. Here is Robbins' initial line of questioning:

I am in the process of editing the tapes of your lectures at Gordon-Conwell and am enjoying them immensely. I notice that you read a few unpublished papers; if you would like to publish them or any of them, we’d be glad to put them in the Trinity Review. 

I have, of course, several questions that I would like to ask you, but I will bring up only one here. You seem to go out of your way to stress that you are not infallible “at any point.” I believe that is a direction quotation. The statement is repeated several times. 

Yet I recall reading in one of your books that you can be infallible any time you wish, simply by reading the infallible word. 

So let me pose the question directly: Are you fallible what [when] you say: A is A? Either A or non-A? Not both A and non-A? In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth? In the beginning was the Logos, and the Logos was with God and the Logos was God? Is it possible that you err when you make these statements? Are you not infallible when you – to use Van Til’s phrase – think God’s thoughts after him? 

If your reply is that you remain fallible even when speaking Truth, what implications does your statement have? Are you not implying a neoorthodox theory that says that God’s Truth can be communicated through fallible means? 

Is it not one thing to say that all synods and councils may err – and all individuals as well – and another thing to say that they may err at every point? 

But perhaps you are attaching a different meaning to infallible than simply “incapable of erring.” 

In Heaven, won’t we be infallible at every point?

Here is Clark's disappointing reply:

As for skepticism, you seem to admit that at any time we might make a mistake in geometry. Yet geometry, or math in general, is a subject matter that has less occasions for mistakes than in the more complicated sciences. After you so acknowledge, you turn to axioms. But axioms are not dependent on logical reasons. They are assumed starting points. I do not see how you can be free from the possibility of making a mistake in choosing or in understanding an axiom. Then you write, “Was Peter fallible when he said, ‘You are…the Son of the Living God.’” Then you add, “If he was not, neither are we.” This is an invalid inference. Note that Arius was willing to accept Peter’s words, and he probably was sincere in thinking he understood Peter’s meaning. But Athanasius thought not, John Milton and Isaac Watts agreed more closely with Arius than with Athanasius. Hence when someone quotes Peter’s words, he may not have the same meaning. 
And as for logic, I challenge you to give me the meaning of All a is b. And since you seem to say that you could not possibly be mistaken in choosing an axiom, I would like you to explain how.

This is anti-foundationalism. Clark falls suspect to exactly the sort of "suppositionalism" of which Van Til and Bahnsen accuse him. Clark completely fails to answer Robbins' question about heaven and tries to do the impossible: make abstract possibility epistemically prior to truth. 

Do we here too we find a late development in Clark's views? It is fascinating that Clark seems to have changed his mind to so many bad positions so late in his life (necessitarianism, occasionalism, Nestorianism, etc). I would need to check my notes, but I wonder if there is some correlation between Clark's retirement from eldership and his increased willingness to [badly] speculate. Age could also be a factor. 

On the other hand, this piece of evidence occurs much later than Van Til's lecture. In terms of Clark's thought at the time of 1967 or so, I think Van Til's accusation against Clark holds little water. For instance, Van Til says that Clark's quote from "How May I Know the Bible is Inspired?" comes at the end of the article, but there are actually two full subheadings after the quote. In fact, a mere two paragraphs after the above citation, Clark's cites and agrees Calvin on our ability to know the Bible in a manner completely contradictory to his above letter to Robbins:

Against this claim the Reformers developed the doctrine of the testimony of the Holy Spirit. The belief that the Bible is the Word of God, so they taught, is neither the result of a papal pronouncement nor a conclusion inferred from prior premises; it is a belief which the Holy Spirit himself produces in our minds. Calvin wrote: “It is therefore such a persuasion as requires no reason; such a knowledge as is supported by the highest reason and in which the mind rests with greater security and constancy than in any reasons; in fine, such a sense as cannot be produced but by a revelation from heaven” (Institutes, I.vii.5)... 

The second phrase in the quotation from Calvin says that, the mind can rest in this knowledge with greater security than in any reasons. This is obvious because the security of a conclusion can be no greater than that of the premise on which it is based. That the sum of the squares on the other two sides is equal to the square of the hypotenuse cannot be any more certain than the axioms from which it is deduced.

Notice that Clark affirms Calvin's statement as "obvious" and elaborates that our "knowledge" "that the Bible is the Word of God" is either certain or we cannot be certain of whatever we deduce from the Bible qua axiom. Likewise, Clark also consistently taught the self-authenticating nature of divine revelation:

Nothing in Paul suggests that the word of “cooperative investigation” (1:20) is more certain or reliable than the wisdom of God. Is it not strange that for any evangelical, for whom sola Scriptura is the formal principle of theology, should try to base the truth of Scripture on the conclusions of Dr. Albright and Miss Kenyon? For Paul revelation is self-authenticating. Athens, Oxford, and American universities have nothing in common with Jerusalem. (First Corinthians, 1991, pg. 58)

How then could God show to a man that it was God speaking? Suppose God should say, “I will make of you a great nation...and I will bless them that bless you and curse him that curses you.” Would God call the devil and ask Abraham to believe the devil’s corroborative statements? Is the devil’s word good evidence of God’s veracity? It would not seem so. Nor is the solution to be found in God’s appealing to another man in order to convince the doubter. Aside from the fact that this other man is no more of an authority than the devil, the main question reappears unanswered in this case also. What reasons can this man have to conclude that God is making a revelation to him? It is inherent in the very nature of the case that the best witness to God’s existence and revelation is God himself. There can be no higher source of truth. God may, to be sure, furnish “evidence” to man. He may send an earthquake, a fire, or still small voice; he may work spectacular miracles, or, as in the cases of Isaiah and Peter, he may produce inwardly an awful consciousness of sin, so that the recipient of the revelation is compelled to cry out, “Woe is me! For I am undone, because I am a man of unclean lips.” But whether it be an external spectacle or an inward “horror or great darkness,” all of this is God’s witnessing to himself. (A Christian View of Men and Things, 2005, pgs. 182-183)

What is a claim that God's revealed word is self-authenticating other than the one can be non-inferentially, epistemically justified and know that God's revealed word is authentic, genuine, and true? I think the evidence suggests Clark changed his mind than that he held "suppositionalism" throughout his life.

What then did Clark mean in the first quote from "How May I Know the Bible is Inspired" above? Firstly, Clark acknowledges that the systems of Christianity and non-Christianity are completely opposed: "in logical theory there is no proposition on which a consistent believer and a consistent unbeliever can agree." Van Til may object to the idea of a "consistent" unbeliever, but that returns us to common ground discussion, for Clark is just saying that an unbeliever can "inconsistently" understand and affirm truth. This, we saw, Van Til and several complainants apparently deny. 

But if "the law of contradiction is a law that God has implanted logic in the creature made in his image" (minute mark 16:24), we must ask whether the implanting is rooted out by the Fall. If not, then while the system of an unbeliever will fail to enable a correct use of said law, less "consistent" unbelievers may themselves use the law correctly, implicitly opposing their own, avowed systems (sometimes, without even realizing it). This ground, pardon the pun, was already covered earlier, so I'll move on.

Secondly, there is a clear emphasis from Clark on what or how unbelievers "regard" or are "thinking." Are they more or less consistent? That will influence a Christian's interaction with them. The more "consistent" or deeper an unbeliever sinks into reprobate thinking, the less a Christian will be able to engage. There is a good Clark quote I cannot quite recall in which he essentially says that it would be insane to try to reason with the insane. 

On the other hand, unbelievers who inconsistently affirm truths are more accessible to a Christian apologetic. We can more easily highlight their inconsistency to accept truth with their false worldview. Even in this case, though, unbelievers will refuse any logical defenses we offer. The unbeliever who states accepts logic (inconsistently) will still, unless the Holy Spirit convicts them, reject our logical arguments. They might "regard" logical consistency as "evidence for inspiration," but because they abstract logic from the only worldview in which it can be situated, anything is possible, even "a most remarkable accident" such as the Bible. There are no end to excuses one might hear; grace is always needed.

If it seems I'm doing some gymnastics to defend Clark, I am only trying to be as charitable to him as I have tried to be with Van Til. The numerous quotes I've provided will hopefully provide some context. It's also worth pointing out that we saw Van Til admit in his lecture that Clark "virtually... says" that "the law of contradiction cannot work in a chance universe" (read again Clark's statement that "in logical theory there is no proposition on which a consistent believer and a consistent unbeliever can agree"). What Van Til sees from Clark as an actual admission that the truth of Christianity "may all depend" has, I content, a better, alternative explanation.

No one's theology nor historical accuracy in this post has been entirely without fault. I myself am capable of misrepresenting all of these men, but I have tried to document my position with specific examples. This is the sort of topic that probably requires a book-length treatment for anything resembling a resolution of views which have been argued for 80 years. It will probably require someone who has read both men and others deeply. This is challenging, because there are important documents (at least by or involving Clark) that remain publicly unavailable or unread. In time, I hope that changes.

For more on the idea Clark accepted "suppositionalism" or had a worldview in which he fundamentalized hypotheticals, see here.

Tuesday, June 7, 2022

Clark on Salvation, Sanctification, and Synergism

While writing a review the Appendix to Scripturalism and the Senses, a slightly off-topic comment Mr. Lazar made recalled to mind a similar position staked out by John Robbins. Mr. Lazar writes, "Clark denied an Arminian can 'consistently be assured of his salvation' because they deny divine monergism. Instead, they believe in synergism—that man cooperates (ergism) with (syn) God in salvation" (pg. 162). 

Mr. Lazar provides no relevant citation for this assertion. Instead, what is referenced - and is true - is that Clark denied that Arminians can consistently have assurance due to their affirmation of libertarian free will, freedom which would logically preclude knowledge of whether they may deny the faith in the future. For example:

...if predestination is false, what becomes of our assurance of salvation and the perseverance of the saints? If God has not from all eternity decided to preserve me in grace, do I have any spiritual power in myself to persevere to the end? And if I have such power, would not salvation be achieved through my own efforts and by my own merits, rather than by God's grace? (link)

Clark, of course, rejected libertarian free will. Yet - as I've argued elsewhere (link, link, link, link) Clark also held that synergism - "that man cooperates (ergism) with (syn) God in salvation" - does occur, at least within the salvific context of progressive sanctification. While a proper understanding of such synergy presupposes the predestination of God to preserve us in grace, these two ideas do not conflict. The following eight citations, all written at various times in Clark's life, are evidences of this fact:

When we consider the omnipotence of God, we may wonder why he does not accomplish the work of purification and sanctification in us instantaneously. God could, no doubt, make us perfect all at once, but, none the less, he takes time. Some people chafe under the burden of becoming righteous slowly; they look for some short-cut. If God justifies by faith, they ask, why does he not also sanctify by faith? And because of impatience, a few Christians try to satisfy themselves with a perfection which, though not perfect, is at least apparently attainable all at once. The Scriptures, however, teach something different. We have seen that our members must be instruments of righteousness; in the verse following, (Rom. 6:16ff) we have the illustration of slavery and servitude, which obviously is not an instantaneous act, but a continuous condition of life. The point is stressed in other passages of Scripture. Phil. 2:12, 13 says, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling of course, God works in us; the point to be noted is that it is a work and not a single act. Or we may turn to Gal. 6:5, which says, every man shall bear his own burden. The Christian life, then, has burdens that take time to bear. Or again, in 1 Cor. 3:9, we are laborers together with God. Therefore we should not indulge ourselves in the hope of an easy, instantaneous sanctification, but rather run with patience the race that is set before us. (1945. Romans Six. The Quarryvillian, 1 June, 2, link)
That sanctification is a struggle is plainly stated in Scripture. Romans 7:23 and its context show how Paul struggled. Note that he is here describing his experiences after regeneration. He could not earlier have said, “I delight in the law of God after the inward man.” The phrase in 2 Corinthians 10:3, “For though we walk in the flesh, we do not war after the flesh,” indicates a war. Paul here makes a play of words by using flesh in two different senses First Timothy 1:18 describes Timothy’s sanctification as a good warfare. And in 6:12 Paul urges him to “Fight the good fight of faith.” See also 2 Timothy 2:3.
But the fullest statement that the Christian life is a warfare comes in Ephesians 6:10-17. The whole armor of God is needed to withstand the wiles of the devil; we wrestle against the rulers of darkness; we need a breastplate, a shield, a helmet, and especially a sword. And we need perseverance. 
The theologian today and the man in the pews must recognize that this warfare is conducted in the power of the Spirit. Were not the right man on our side, our striving would be losing. 
But there is a difference between regeneration and sanctification. As to the former, “we are altogether passive therein.” In the latter we struggle. One must not deny either the Spirit’s power or our activity. 
Certain popular Bible teachers have been so impressed by the power of the Spirit that they deny our need to struggle. When I was a boy, my aunt, previously a missionary to the Mormons, gave me Hannah Smith’s The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life. Fortunately I was too young to understand it. Somewhat hypocritically, as it seems to me now, Mrs. Smith wrote in her Preface, “I do not want to change the theological views of a single individual. The truths I have to tell are not theological, but practical” (p. vi). When she adds, “They will fit in with every creed, she is certainly asserting a falsehood.
The Keswick movement, of which I think Mrs. Smith and her husband were a part, used such phrases as “Let go, and let God”; “We must not try to sin”; “Let him do it all.” For example, Mrs. Smith declares, “Man’s part is to trust, and God’s part is to work…. Either we must do it for ourselves, or someone must do it for us… it is something we are unable to do…. Plainly the believer can do nothing but trust…. Surrender and trust… is positively all the man can do We do not do anything, but He does it” (p. 29-31). 
As a dedicated, and many will say extreme, Calvinist, I more than gladly insist on God’s doings. No one understands much of the Bible unless he believes in sovereign predestination. But if God predestinated Calvin to write the Institutes, and if God has predestinated me to write this greatly inferior booklet, it was nonetheless Calvin and it is nonetheless I who must put down the words on paper. Mrs. Smith’s statement, “Either we must do it ourselves, or someone must do it for us,” is in its context a false disjunction. Both Calvin and God did the Institutes. And in an even stricter sense both God and Moses wrote the Pentateuch. They cooperated, and as in all cooperation their precise activities in producing the result were different. God is the source of our abilities and the effective determiner of how we use them. But it is we ourselves who must fight the good fight and run the straight race through God’s grace. (The Holy Spirit, pgs. 46-48) 
But there is a difference between regeneration and sanctification. As to the former “we are altogether passive therein.” In the latter we struggle. One must not deny either the Spirit’s power or our activity. The two of us must cooperate. You see there is no synergism is regeneration, but there is in sanctification. (Audio lecture on Sanctification, link)
Sanctification is the life process of growing in holiness. And this requires effort (Gal. 5:17; Jas. 4:7; I Pet. 2:11). (The Biblical Expositor: Volume III, pg. 249) 
Not only do destructive critics make such mistakes; many sincere and devout worshippers are also confused. They often say that we are saved by faith alone. This of course is false. We are justified by faith alone; but we are regenerated without any previous faith or works; we are sanctified by faith and works; and we shall be glorified by neither. A closer study of Scripture would help us avoid confusion relative to the several distinct phases of an all-inclusive salvation. (The Pastoral Epistles, pg. 133) 

What then is the object of fear in these verses? To begin with, is it plausible that Paul is warning the Philippians to fear damnation when he himself was confident (1:6 says confident or being persuaded) that God would complete the work he had begun? Notice that in some instances the antonym of fear is pride. Proverbs 23:17 speaks of fear as reverence or submission. Proverbs 28:4 contrasts fear with the hardening of the heart. Hebrews 12:28 speaks of reverence and godly fear. In 1 Peter 1:17 fear is virtually gratitude and awe. Jeremiah 32:40 says, “I will put my fear in their hearts that they shall not depart from me.” The fear itself is a basis of assurance and confidence. Does this not cover the Arminians with shame?

It must also be noted that salvation has several aspects. Some people say, “I was saved on December 31 at 6:05 p.m.” If the statement is true, it can mean only that they were regenerated at that time. But sanctification and eventually glorification are also parts of salvation. Therefore when Paul says, “Work out your own salvation,” thereby indicating a process, he is referring to sanctification and not to regeneration. Once again this ties in with God’s beginning a work that proceeds go to completion. In this process, as is absolutely not the case in regeneration or justification, we have some work to do. And God works in us, not only to do such work, but beforehand to will such work. (Philippians, pgs. 73-74)

Let us be quite clear on the fact that the Bible does not teach salvation by faith alone. The Bible teaches justification by faith alone. Justification then necessarily is followed by a process of sanctification, and this consists of works which we do. It consists of external actions initiated by internal volitions. We must therefore work out our own salvation; and this in fear and trembling, because we must depend on God. (Predestination, Chapter 6)

An associated group, the World Evangelical Fellowship, has a slightly different creed. One of its phrases is ‘salvation by faith apart from works.’ This surely is not Romish, but neither is it evangelical; for while the Bible definitely teaches justification by faith alone, it also teaches that sanctification, an essential part of salvation, involves a life of good works. See Romans 6. (1958. Fundamentalists, Evangelicals, and Billy Graham, The Reformed Presbyterian Advocate Vol 92 No 6, June-July: 65-66, 70, 76, link)  

I believe these demonstrate that in Clark's mind (and mine), a proper understanding of "synergism" or co-operation does not entail libertarian free will. That is, contrary to Arminians, "God is the source of our abilities and the effective determiner of how we use them." But, contrary to Mr. Lazar, we are not "altogether passive" in progressive sanctification (as monergism would imply), a phase or aspect of "salvation." In progressive sanctification - indeed, in the normal case of saving faith, a point to which I will return below - we use our own abilities in cooperation with God, having been predestined or determined by Him to use those abilities. 

I am aware of others who admire Clark yet disagreed with him about this. While I think it was a bad idea (for more than one reason), John Robbins, for instance, inserted a rare, editorial rebuke of Clark in the 1987 TrinityFoundation reprint of Predestination, writing:

From here to the end of the paragraph Dr. Clark errs in two ways. First, the Bible emphatically teaches salvation by faith alone: “Your faith has saved you; go in peace” (Luke 7:50). “Those by the way side are they that hear; then comes the devil, and takes away the Word out of their hearts, lest they should believe and be saved” (Luke 8:12). “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believes in him should not perish, but have everlasting life” (John 3:16). “And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved” (Acts 2:21). “Who will tell you words, by which you and all your house shall be saved” (Acts 11:14). “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and you shall be saved” (Acts 16:31). “That if you shall confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus, and shall believe in your heart that God has raised him from the dead, you shall be saved” (Romans 10:9). “By which also you are saved, if you keep in memory what I preached unto you, unless you have believed in vain” (1 Corinthians 15:2). “For by grace are you saved, through faith” (Ephesians 2:8). “…it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching to save them that believe” (1 Corinthians 1:21). “…them that perish; because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved” (2 Thessalonians 2:10). “God has from the beginning chosen you to salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth” (2 Thessalonians 2:13). “But we are not of them who draw back unto perdition; but of them that believe to the saving of the soul” (Hebrews 10:39).

We see in these verses that justification is not an aspect of salvation on a par with other aspects, but is so identified with salvation that the terms are interchanged repeatedly. To be justified – to be declared righteous because of the imputation of Christ’s perfect righteousness – is to be saved. All else – sanctification, good works, glorification – flow from that.

Second, Dr. Clark errs when he says that sanctification “consists of works which we do” and “of external actions initiated by internal volitions” and that “we do the things that produce sanctification.” All these statements are in error. Sanctification is the work of the Holy Spirit; it is not something we do, nor is it the result of something we do. Question 75 of the Larger Catechism asks, “What is sanctification?” and answers: “Sanctification is a work of God’s grace….” In the Westminster Confession of Faith, the chapter on Sanctification is separate from and precedes the chapter on Good Works. To show that sanctification is the work of the Holy Spirit, not of ourselves, it cites such verses as 1 Corinthians 6:10: “…but you are washed, you are sanctified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God.” John 17:17: “Sanctify them through your truth: Your Word is truth.” Ephesians 5:26: “That he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the Word.” 1 Thessalonians 5:23: “And the very God of peace sanctify you wholly….” Good works neither are sanctification nor do they produce sanctification. Good works are an effect, a result of sanctification by the Spirit.

Dr. Clark knew all this, for in his book Sanctification, he wrote, “Chapter 13 of the Westminster Confession emphasizes the fact that we are sanctified by God, not by our own efforts; an imperfect obedience to the moral law is a result of that sanctification, not the cause of it.” He concludes his book with the words of Christ from John 17: “Sanctify them by your truth. Your Word is truth.” (John Robbins, Predestination, footnote 9 in the chapter on Free Will)

What can be said in reply to Robbins? Personally, I consider the aforementioned citations of Clark sufficient to show what Clark actually believed, why, and why his beliefs are well founded. But a few further comments can be made. To the first of Robbins' criticisms, there can be no question what Clark's view about the meaning of "salvation." As already has been alluded to above and will be highlighted again, Clark believed "salvation" could, depending on a context, refer to related but distinct events or to the broad encompassment of all of these events:

Furthermore, although there is no space here to argue it, justification inevitably issues in sanctification. True grace and true faith never fail in this life to produce good works. Nothing in this article is to be thought to contradict the necessity of preparing for a future life on a new earth wherein dwelleth righteousness. Salvation has several elements, including regeneration, justification, sanctification, glorification. But they are different elements. (1973. Concerning Justification. Christianity Today Mar. 16, link) 

In light of all of this, I can easily conceive of how someone might mistakenly (or deceptively) believe how what I have put in bold in the following quotations could suggest Clark believed that "salvation" is monergistic (ignore the italics for now, to which I will return below): 

It is sad that some Christians – perhaps some even in our own church, do not enthusiastically receive the doctrine of election, for if God did not take the initiative, it is certain that the sinful heart of man never would.

There is a story of an elderly gentleman, a faithful Christian for many long years, who once testified, “I am saved because God and I cooperated; I did my part, and God did His.” The people were astonished at this testimony, as he expected them to be; and after waiting a moment to let the people wonder what he might have contributed to his salvation, he continued, “I resisted, and God did the rest.”

Peter knew that God had taken and had kept the initiative in his case. He was not offended at the notion of election, for he saw in it the source of all his blessings. Therefore he could write to us with joy that “ye are a chosen generation . . . that ye should show forth the praises of him who hath called you out of darkness into his marvelous light.” We also should rejoice in God’s electing grace. (1947. Elect Unto Obedience, A Sermon Prepared at the General Conference of Quarryville. The Witness Jul: 3-4.)

The Arminian system holds (1) that God elects persons to eternal life on the condition of their reception of grace and their perseverance as foreseen; (2) that Christ died, not as the substitute for certain men, definitely to assume their penalty, but to render a chance of salvation indifferently possible to all men; (3) that all men have the same influence of the Holy Ghost operating on them, so that some are saved because they cooperate, and others are lost because they resist, thus in effect making salvation depend on the will of man; and (4) that since salvation is not made certain by God's decree nor by Christ's sacrifice, and since man's will is free or independent of God's control, a regenerate man can unregenerate himself and ultimately be lost.

In contrast the Calvinist, the Confession, and the Bible teach (1) that election is unconditional and that sovereign grace is irresistible; (2) that Christ offers us a difference, you know; (3) that human cooperation is not the cause of regeneration, which depends on God and not on the will of man; and (4) that the new birth begins an eternal life, i.e. a life that does not end in a year or two. (1955. Assurance. The Southern Presbyterian Journal, Jan. 19)

In contrast with the pope’s claim to be the vicar of Christ, in contrast also with the practice of praying to the Virgin and to saints, the Scriptures place no barrier between man and God. The apostle Paul in 1 Tim. 2:5 says, “There is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus.” Sinful man indeed needs a mediator in order to approach God, but that mediator is the God-Man, Jesus Christ. Any reliance on priests, saints, the Virgin, or the pope constitutes a rejection of Christ. Christ is sufficient for our salvation; he does not need to be helped out. (link)

A hasty glance would perhaps lead one to mistakenly infer that Clark is, at times, inconsistent. For these citations do initially seem to suggest that unlike, say, Arminians or Roman Catholics, a Calvinist should not think that we "cooperate" or "help out" in "salvation." But when we look at the bold quotations in context - specifically, the italicized statements - one should begin to understand that what Clark is actually saying is that man does not cooperate or help out in certain soteric or salvific events. 

The context of the first citation discusses election. The context of the second citation discusses regeneration. The context of the third citation discusses mediation. Strictly speaking, in each of these aspects of salvation, I certainly agree with Clark that there is no synergism. But such does not deny a proper understanding of synergism in other "elements" of salvation or in "salvation" broadly considered as an overarching concept that includes some synergistic elements (like sanctification).

Returning to Robbins' first argument against Clark, then, he strangely cites 2 Thessalonians 2:13 as support for his position (which is contrary to Clark's) that "salvation" and "justification" are interchangeable and equivalent. But read the verse and try to substitute "justification" for "salvation." Would Robbins say that Paul meant, "God has from the beginning chosen you to [justification] through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth"? Does Robbins think justification comes through progressive sanctification? On the contrary, Clark's own commentary on 2 Thessalonians 2:13-14 aims to show that Robbins is wrong to equate "salvation" with only one event:

Since God is omniscient, which a pastor of the Moody Church in Chicago discreetly but in consistency denied some fifty years ago, since, therefore, all his plans form an inviolable system, his choice has several determinate results. Here Paul mentions two: first, salvation in the form of sanctification; and second, belief in the truth. Common parlance among evangelistically-minded witnesses is usually confused. In witnessing, when one asks a prospect, “Are you saved?” he really means, “Have you been regenerated?” But regeneration is only a part, the initial part, of salvation. Then salvation continues in the form of sanctification; and finally, there is glorification, which comes at death and is to be completed at our resurrection. Here Paul has confined his thought to sanctification and its immediate cause, belief in the truth. (Commentaries on Paul's Epistles, pgs. 319-320)

Perhaps Robbins would object to this as well and argue that in this context, sanctification refers to regeneration. 

Even so, on Robbins' own position, justification and [progressive] sanctification depend on faith, something we do indeed "do" (Acts 16:30-31). God alone indeed declares a man righteous in Christ - and in this sense, justification can be viewed as monergistic. But because justification in turn depends on saving faith, and because saving faith is something we "do," God's monergistic declaration depends on a synergistic cooperation. Of course, having faith is something we can "do" solely by God's grace, but this is besides the point. 

Or to put things another way, we are, as Robbins says, sanctified by the truth, but not by a passive experience of truth. A reprobate can hear truth without it sanctifying him. 2 Thessalonians 2:13 shows that it is our belief in the truth through which we are saved, and actual belief is a volitional activity or act of will, as Clark argued (link). Thus, the point is that even on Robbins' view, a proper understanding of synergistic cooperation is involved in our "salvation" (link). 

Incidentally, I think this admission enables admirers of Clark to revisit his view of the nature of saving faith. Once it is admitted that all sides agree saving faith is an obedience to the gospel - not that it is itself our merit or ground for justification (link) - there is less worry about what additional element (e.g. "trust" or "dependence") saving faith might include besides understanding and assent, so long as said element is also not taken to be merit or ground for justification. But I have attempted this elsewhere (link, link) and will look to reexamine such things in my final review of Mr. Lazar's book.

Finally, then, what of Robbins' last point about what Clark wrote on the last page in his book Sanctification? The following could be read as contradicting what I have noted Clark has said elsewhere about progressive sanctification: 

Dr. Clark knew all this, for in his book Sanctification, he wrote, "Chapter 13 of the Westminster Confession emphasizes the fact that we are sanctified by God, not by our own efforts; an imperfect obedience to the moral law is a result of that sanctification, not the cause of it." (Sanctification, pg. 100)

What is slightly deceptive about this quote is that Robbins does not include Clark's next sentence which rounds out an entire paragraph: "Sanctification begins with regeneration." Robbins really ought to have included this line for transparency, for with this context, I think what Clark says above is easily harmonized with the many statements already cited. For I don't consider Clark to be talking about progressive sanctification at all.

Reread Clark's statement Robbins cites with the context of regeneration in mind: "we are all sanctified" (read: a salvific completed event in the past = "regenerated") "by God, not by our own efforts." Regeneration is, as was already mentioned, monergistic. Further, any "imperfect obedience to the moral law is a result of that sanctification" (read: regeneration), "not the cause of it." We don't obey to become regenerate, we become regenerate by which we can and will then obey. In other words, I would argue that in what Robbins cites, Clark is speaking about regeneration, not progressive sanctification.

If anyone does not find this interpretation of Clark's final page in Sanctification convincing, the coup de grace is that Sanctification was not originally written as a standalone book. Clark initially intended it to be chapter 8 in a systematic theology of sorts (link). 

Why is this important? Because in chapter 7 (appropriately entitled Salvation!) of that same systematic theology to which we now have access - and perhaps Robbins did not at the time when he published Sanctification (1992) - Clark makes statements that support the same, consistent interpretation of him that I have already provided above. In the first section of chapter 7, Clark confirms his position (against Robbins) about the meaning of "salvation":

The title Salvation is doubtless too broad as an accurate indication of this chapter's contents. But it is not so narrow as one of its common uses. Some untutored people use the term as a synonym for regeneration. They speak of someone or themselves as being "saved" at a certain time, without having in mind any notion of justification or sanctification. Salvation, however, includes these. It is regeneration plus all the spiritual blessings that succeed upon it. For this reason salvation is incomplete without resurrection and glorification in heaven.

Nevertheless, eschatology with the promise of resurrection, the return of Christ, glorification, heaven, and the penalty of hell too, is such an extensive topic, that though all of it is a part of salvation, it will be reserved for the final chapter. The main topics here are Regeneration, Faith, Justification, and Sanctification. This is already too much for one chapter, and to alleviate the length there will be a division into parts... 

That Clark believed salvation includes justification, sanctification, et al. should be obvious by now. But note what Clark means by the last paragraph. Remembering that this is chapter 7 of a larger systematic theology, and taking note of what is outlined in the table of contents for this systematic theology, Clark is saying that in the rest of this chapter on Salvation, he will discuss regeneration, saving faith, and justification. He will reserve comment on sanctification and eschatology for following chapters, because it would be too much material to include in this chapter. 

Thus, Sanctification, chapter 8, will follow what else Clark says in this chapter. Anything in chapter 8 - that is to say, any inference that Robbins or anyone else makes from Clark's statements in Sanctification, the book published by the TrinityFoundation in 1992 - really ought to be agree with what Clark writes in chapter 7. But in chapter 7, Clark repeatedly says that [progressive] sanctification involves [a proper understanding of] synergy between God and man: 

At this point, between regeneration and faith, it is appropriate to insert a paragraph or two on the idea of grace. Not that such paragraphs will contain much more than what has already been said, or at least implied, for the material on regeneration is particularly clear on the point that it is God's work, not ours. Of course, after regeneration there comes a process of sanctification, to be considered in the next chapter, in which process there is ample room for our good works. But even so, we depend on grace to accomplish them…

What the Romanists call justification most assuredly depends partly on works; but what they call justification is not what the Bible means by the term. Their use of the term is essentially the equivalent of sanctification. Of course this requires good works…

God is judged, and pronounced just. God is not made just; he is pronounced or acknowledged to be just. The fourth verse, "By the works of the law no flesh shall be justified," supports the same conclusion because the works of the law are essential to sanctification…

Regeneration produces (subjective effects, particularly faith) and sanctification inevitably follows justification. An alleged faith that results in no good works is not saving faith at all. (link)

Clark says that of course sanctification most assuredly depends partly on good works. I can't imagine how he could be more plain or blunt. Can anyone seriously think that Clark wrote the above statements but then, only one chapter later, contradicted himself by actually meaning to suggest that progressive sanctification does not include human effort or obedience... especially given that this would also contradict what he says everywhere else? Or does it not make more sense that Clark was specifically referring to the beginning of sanctification - i.e. regeneration - as he himself mentions in context?

To conclude this post, one might disagree with Clark. I happen to think Clark's position protects against antinomianism, of which I find Mr. Lazar and Robbins in danger of admitting. But an accurate understanding of Clark's view is a precondition for approval or disagreement. That is what I have been concerned to straighten out by this post and hope to have done.

Sunday, May 22, 2022

Simply Yes or No

Every so often, I see a man by the name of Berj Manoushagian attempt to influence readers of Gordon Clark that only one proposition is true: Jesus Christ is Lord (link). What Berj makes of Psalm 119:160, 1 Kings 17:24, etc., I do not pretend to understand. Nor do I find that it makes much sense that he would attempt to influence anyone by means of propositions which he admits are not true. For whatever reason, Berj himself seems to find the work of logical positivists like Hans Hahn - who denied the possibility of metaphysics (link) - influential. Clark handily dealt with nonsense such as this during his lifetime. There would be little reason for me to mention any of this except that Berj has cited Clark as supporting his views.

One method Berj uses to argue that there is only one proposition is that the Law of Excluded Middle "must be discarded." Berj wants to discard the Law of Excluded Middle, I believe, so that no one can accuse him of counting Scriptural propositions as false. As Scripture refers to its own statements as truth, however, his merely allowing that they are not false is insufficient, a point he studiously avoids. 

My interest, however, is more so that Berj thinks Clark and John Robbins wrote statements supporting a denial of the Law of Excluded Middle in favor of a view that some propositions are neither true nor false:

The “Law of Excluded Middle” states that every proposition must be either True or False.

This “law” must be discarded.

Its acceptance hinders the study of meaningful propositions, and is incompatible with the nature of reality and the nature of Truth.

The Quotations given below are in support of the necessity for a third category. (link)

The following are what statements Clark and Robbins made which Berj interprets as denials of the Law of Excluded Middle (emphases his):

A proposition therefore is defined as the meaning of a declarative sentence. Some sentences are not declarative, such as commands in the imperative mood, or exhortations in the well-nigh extinct subjunctive mood. Questions, or interrogative sentences, also are neither true nor false. Only declarative sentences are true or false; and it is this common character that is important for propositions. Of course in English rhetoric there are questions that are intended as propositions. They are called rhetorical questions. They are an embellishment of style. They spruce up a speech. But logically they are propositions. A question that is intended as a question is neither true nor false. It can play no part in an argument.

Let us now return– an exhortation, neither true nor false, but one which it is hoped that the student will follow– to the simplest propositions and the simplest form of arguments.
Gordon Clark; Logic; 1988; p30

As I said earlier, single words without context are neither true nor false.
J. W. Robbins; Without a Prayer; 1997; p78

Ignorance is neither true nor false.
J. W. Robbins

Now, in what way Berj thinks these statements imply a denial of the Law of Excluded Middle is anyone's guess, for they in no way do so. He even quotes Clark as specifically defining a proposition as "the meaning of a declarative sentence." If Berj is arguing that some propositions are neither true nor false, it is of no help to him to cite Clark and Robbins discussing "single words," "ignorance," "questions," or "an exhortation," for none of these are declarative sentences. Thus, none of these - at least in Clark's mind - are propositions, so none of these have any bearing of the Law of Excluded Middle.

As for what Clark actually believed regarding the Law of Excluded Middle, what he says below simultaneously refutes Berj's position and defends Clark's own:

The law of identity, a is a, and the principle of disjunction also fall under Curtis’ condemnation. For a reason he does not state, he objects to the assertion, If I am an historian, I either follow F. J. Turner or I do not. But apparently his conscience pricks him a little, for he admits that it is legitimate to say, Either I am a Christian or I am not. But by what principle can he reject disjunction in history and retain it in religion? If disjunction or excluded middle is a fallacious form of thought, it can never be used legitimately; but if it is legitimate in one case, all the misapplications of slovenly thinkers will not serve to invalidate its proper universality. 
...if a word is to convey a meaning, it must not only mean something; it must also not mean something. If it had an infinite number of meanings, if the term man had the meanings of all the words in the dictionary, it would be useless in speech. In fine, if man means not-man, the sentence, Socrates is a man, means nothing. But those who deny the law of contradiction identify man and not-man. Those who deny the law of excluded middle assert that Socrates is neither man nor not-man. What they say is nonsense. Nothing sensible can be said without using the laws they deny. (1956. Logic and Language, The Gordon Review Vol. II No. 1 Feb)

Finally, readers should carefully consider whether Jesus' disjunctive words in Matthew 5:37 or John 8:42-45 are or are not truth as well as who Jesus says is the father is of one who denies that they are truth:

Matthew 5:37 Let what you say be simply ‘Yes’ or ‘No’; anything more than this comes from evil.
John 8:42 Jesus said to them, “If God were your Father, you would love me, for I came from God and I am here. I came not of my own accord, but he sent me. 43 Why do you not understand what I say? It is because you cannot bear to hear my word. 44 You are of your father the devil, and your will is to do your father's desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies. 45 But because I tell the truth, you do not believe me.

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Behind Closed Doors

A while ago, I posted a conversation from a Clark discussion board between myself and Monty Collier on the subject of synergism and sanctification (link). This board has also been quite useful in my working out a coherent view of the Trinity and self-knowledge, among other doctrines. For example, recently, Sean Gerety directed the following post by John Robbins at myself and another member:

Folks,  
It seems that when a discussion gets underway on this list some members prefer to return to the question of whether one can now know one is saved. Then follows all sorts of confusion that would take days to sort out, probably to no one's satisfaction. So no progress is made.   
First, the issue is not skepticism. Even if a sinner cannot know (in the proper sense of the word) that he is saved -- and so far no one has shown that he can -- Scripturalism furnishes us with many truths when all other methods fail, and so skepticism is avoided.  
Second, knowledge requires explicit statements in Scripture or deductions from Scripture. It is not the same as assurance or certitude or certainty.  
Third, opinions may be true or false. (It is absurd to say that some propositions are neither true nor false.) So Jack's (a hypothetical person) opinion that he is saved may indeed be true, but no one has yet shown how he can deduce it from Scripture. Those who think he can so deduce it must show how it can be so deduced -- but don't try it here for at least a year.  
Fourth, Jack's failure is not due to any doubt about Scripture (and it is impossible to doubt a proposition one believes -- one either assents or one does not) but solely to the problem of self-knowledge. He knows the major premise, All believers are saved. He opines the minor premise, I am a believer. Therefore the conclusion, I am saved, can rise no higher than opinion. 
Finally, the question is not how does one know one knows? but how does one know? Scripturalism says, one knows only by explicit statements in or valid inferences from Scripture. 
Now, gentlemen, move on to another topic. 

My reply was short:

Sean, do you opine the canon of Scripture or know it? If the former, does that not mean your axiom and its attendant theorems could be false, in which case knowledge is impossible? If the latter, do you not agree that such would necessitate that you are regenerate due to the fact only God's sheep listen to, hear, and follow the voice of the Shepherd (1 John 4, John 8, 10)? If so, then why isn't that self-knowledge? Or if you would not agree, why not? 

Unfortunately but unsurprisingly, I never received a response to this inquiry. After three or four other members made arguments for self-knowledge from Scripture and the WCF, Sean singled out one, a person who with whom I've corresponded for years, by writing:


Mary, do you think someone who denies that Jesus Christ is the one true God and Lord, maker of heaven and earth (John 1:1-3), has any reason to believe, or if you prefer, know, they are a child of God?

Aside from the fact John 1:1-3 does not mention "the one true God," it will not escape the attention of the critical reader that Sean is changing the subject. He started a discussion on self-knowledge. When faced with several challenging objections to his skeptical position, he transitions to Trinitarianism.

Now, I have no objection to discussing Trinitarianism and have done so for months. But I've had enough conversations with Sean to recognize his bait-and-switch. Clearly, Sean's comment is irrelevant to the topic he started. For even if we suppose I am not a Christian, would this refute my argument? No. Despite our disagreements, I assume Sean considers John 8, 10, and 1 John 4 to be canonical. So if these passages teach that one who is not a sheep is not regenerate and cannot hear, follow, or listen to the voice of the Shepherd, then the argument still appears to stand. That I would not be able to know it would not be relevant to whether Sean could be able to know it.

Nevertheless, although she handled Sean deftly, Sean made a few more misrepresentations before I was able to respond. Naturally, the concern for me which this poster showed prompted me to write a summary of why I hold certain Trinitarian views, correcting Sean where appropriate:

Hi Mary. I'm not sure how much exposure you have had to several issues relevant to why I hold to the Trinitarianism of the Nicene Creed, Novatian, Alexander of Alexandria, Athanasius, and other early church fathers rather than that of Calvin, Van Til, or Clark. So before answering your questions, I thought it would be best to give a broad sketch of some of this material.   
Firstly, I think all Trinitarians would agree with a few tenets:   
1. Monotheism: there is one God. 
2. The Father is God, the Son (Jesus) is God, and the Holy Spirit is God. 
3. The Father is distinct from the Son, and both are distinct from the Spirit. 
4. The Father, Son, and Spirit each univocally though distinctly possess divine attributes: each is omniscient, eternal, good, etc. Each possesses a mind and a will. On the other hand, they are individuated or distinguished from one another by properties: for instance, only the "first person" is the Father, only the "second person" is the Son, and only the "third person" is the Spirit. They have different thoughts (e.g. "I am the Father") and make different choices with their different wills (e.g. "I, the Son, will to die"), though all of these variances are with the same purposes and ends in mind, of course. 
For the past 6 months or so, I have been attempting to reconcile point 1 with point 2. Without qualification, point 2 seems to be an indication of support for tritheism. In fact, I think Sean's position logically resolves either into my own or into tritheism. As it stands, Sean can't consistently affirm point 1, monotheism (see my concluding paragraphs). 
The solution I came to was to affirm that what the phrase "one God" means in point 1 is not the same as what "God" means in point 2. In point 2, I think the word "God" means "divine [nature]" or "deity." The Father, Son, and Spirit are each able to be called "God" because each possesses the divine attributes or divine nature. But "[one] God" has more than one meaning. Clearly, when Jesus is said to be the "Son of God," he is not the Son of a divine nature or set of divine attributes - He is the Son of a particular person, the Father. 
So one meaning of God is Father. Another meaning of God is divine. I think John 1:1-2 supports this: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with [the Father], and the Word was [divine]." The Word was not the Father, which is Sabellianism. Nor was the Word with some abstract divinity, for the Word Himself is divine.   
Now, when we examine the passages in which the New Testament which refer to the "one" God (Mark 10:18, 12:29, 1 Corinthians 8:6, Romans 3:30, Galatians 3:20, Ephesians 4:6, 1 Timothy 2:5, James 2:19) or "[only] true" God (John 3:33, 5:44, 17:3, Romans 3:4, 16:27, 1 Thessalonians 1:9, 1 Timothy 1:17 1 John 5:20), we find that they each refer to the Father alone. Thus, I think monotheism is true because we have one Father: "Have we not all one Father? Has not one God created us? Why then are we faithless to one another, profaning the covenant of our fathers?" (Malachi 2:10). But Trinitarianism is also true because there are three distinct yet equally divine persons. And while this post is primarily about what Scripture and logic dictate - we are Protestants, after all - please note that the Nicene Creed refers to the Father as the one God, not the Trinity. 
You might wonder why the Father alone is called the one God if the Son and Spirit are really equal with Him in respect to their divinity. The reason is to be found in the different properties each possesses. The Father, Son, and Spirit are each equally divine. But only the Father is uncaused: the Son and Spirit are, respectively, eternally begotten and eternally spirated of or from the Father. It is for that reason they are subordinate to the person of the Father. It is analogous to a human relationship between a father and son: when a father begets or generates a son, that son possesses humanity. The son is no less human than is his father. But because the son derives humanity from or has humanity communicated to him from his father, he is subordinate to his father. The obvious difference between this and the Trinity is that the relationship between the Father and Son/Spirit is eternal, not temporal, and divinity is communicated rather than humanity.   
So the Son and Spirit are co-equal in respect to nature but not in respect to person[al properties]. If they were co-equal in the latter case, then there really is no reason that one person should obey the other. The relationships themselves would be arbitrary. 
I think this is a fair summary, and I am of course willing to expand on or point you to posts in which I elaborate on these arguments, so to answer your specific questions: 
"So it is a matter of semantics, then?" 
In one sense, yes, and in another sense, no. Sean seems to deny that "God" can have multiple meanings, so semantics is relevant. But these semantics have significant implications. 
"But Ryan (and I ask this with all humility), when Jesus says I am my Father are ONE---would this language not be considered the same as “one God?”" 
Define "one God." We would agree they are not the same person, right? But isn't the "one God" a person? If so, then doesn't it make more sense to say that Jesus and the Father are one in some other sense (e.g. John 17:11, 21-23)? 
With respect to what Sean says, then, he is lying when he says I deny the full divinity of the Son and Spirit. He is equivocating when he says I don't believe the Son and Spirit are co-equal with the Father. He is raising a red herring in citing Thomas' confession. The truth is, I tried for several months to get him to answer specific questions about Trinitarianism, and he has offered no reply. He says the Father, Son, and Spirit have one will. I ask if the Father willed to die or assume humanity as did the Son. No reply. He says the Son and Spirit are autotheos and aseity. I ask how then the relationships among the Trinity can be non-arbitrary. No reply. He says there is one God because there is one definition of God. I ask if there is one person because there is one definition of person. No reply. He says the Father, Son, and Spirit are inseparable. I ask how that establishes monotheism. No reply. He says I'm a Unitarian. I ask if he thinks the early church - including the primary opponent of Arius with whom my position is in full agreement - was comprised of Unitarians. No reply. [I am being polite when I say his historical understanding of the Trinity is skewed.] Etc. 
So why does he bring up the Trinity now, in a completely different context, after failing to respond for so long? Honestly, it is because he realizes he is facing another uphill struggle on yet another topic: my arguments for the necessity of self-knowledge. In my first post, I use the Socratic method to anticipate the possible responses he could have to my questions. Since the answers to these questions lead to a rejection of his denial of self-knowledge, he blatantly changes the subject, making the same misrepresentations for which I have corrected him dozens of times. He used the same bait-and-switch method when we discussed the Trinity. Will he respond to the arguments I make for the Nicene view of the Trinity in this comment? I really don't have anything else to say. Just watch and see. 
I hope your worries are calmed and that you are doing well. Thank you for your kind words.

I have said all of this on my blog at one time and in one form or another. However, seeing it in all at once puts into perspective how systematic Trinitarianism really is. As I said, the discussion board has been useful. In any case, my prediction about the substance of Sean's reply quickly came to fruition:

While Ryan calls me a liar, keep in mind that despite his attempt to paint his view as "Trinitarian," he admits he rejects any view of the Trinity that would be recognized by "Calvin, Van Til, or Clark" not to mention the Westminster Divines or any Christian church anywhere. Further, while pretending to hold to the Nicene creed (he doesn't) he completely rejects the Athanasian creed which states in part: 
"So there is One Father, not Three Fathers; one Son, not Three Sons; One Holy Ghost, not Three Holy Ghosts. And in this Trinity none is afore or after Other, None is greater or less than Another, but the whole Three Persons are Co-eternal together, and Co-equal. So that in all things, as is aforesaid, the Unity in Trinity, and the Trinity in Unity, is to be worshipped. He therefore that will be saved, must thus think of the Trinity."
I think you'll figure out shortly who is the liar.

Again, what had I just said in my last comment?

"Will he respond to the arguments I make for the Nicene view of the Trinity in this comment? I really don't have anything else to say. Just watch and see." 
Called it. 
Again, this is just what occurred in our discussions several months ago. I make half a dozen or so Scriptural and logical arguments for my view, and Sean passes these by, instead focusing on historical theology. Although Sean is being disingenuous in his representations of this history, even if he weren't, none of it could bind my conscience.
But this is well-trodden ground before. I ask Sean who the Nicene Creed calls the one God, the Trinity or the Father. No reply. I ask Sean whether the Creed says the Son is God of Himself (autotheos) or God of God. No reply. So who is really pretending to hold to the Nicene Creed? Look no further than the person who thinks the Trinity is the one God or that the Son [or Spirit] is autotheos: Sean. 
Does Sean explain why I should accept Calvin, Van Til, or Clark's view? No. Does he explain why I should accept the Athanasian Creed? No. Does he respond to any criticisms of their views which I have made? No. Does he interact with the works of early church fathers on whom I have commented? No... Is this all sounding too familiar? 
Now, if I cared enough, I could perhaps find support for my Trinitarian position in Reformed authors. But given that historical theology isn't conscience-binding, I really find it ridiculous for Sean, a fellow Scripturalists of all things, to use it [with less than stellar effect] as his primary rebuttal. That's a Roman Catholic method, not a Protestant one. Nevertheless, I recall several statements which support my view with which Sean cannot agree. One is given by Jonathan Edwards who, speaking of the immanent Trinity, eternally subordinates the Son and Spirit to the fount of divinity, the Father, so as to non-arbitrarily explain their economic activity: 
"Though a subordination of the Persons of the Trinity in their actings, be not from any proper natural subjection one to another, and so must be conceived of as in some respect established by mutual free agreement, whereby the Persons of the Trinity, of their own will, have as it were formed themselves into a society, for carrying on the great design of glorifying the deity and communicating its fullness, in which is established a certain economy and order of acting. Yet this agreement establishing this economy is not to be looked upon as merely arbitrary, founded on nothing but the mere pleasure of the members of this society, not merely a determination and constitution of wisdom come into from a view to certain ends which it is very convenient for the obtaining. But there is a natural decency or fitness in that order and economy that is established. It is fit that the order of the acting of the Persons of the Trinity should be agreeable to the order of their subsisting. That as the Father is first in the order of subsisting, so he should be first in the order of acting. That as the other two Persons are from the Father in their subsistence, and as to their subsistence naturally originated from him and are dependent on him, so that in all that they act they should originate from him, act from him and in a dependence on him. That as the Father with respect to the subsistences is the fountain of the deity, wholly and entirely so, so he should be the fountain in all the acts of the deity. This is fit and decent in itself. Though it is not proper to say, decency obliges the Persons of the Trinity to come into this order and economy. yet it may be said that decency requires it, and that therefore the Persons of the Trinity all consent to this order, and establish it by agreement, as they all naturally delight in what is in itself fit, suitable and beautiful." 
http://www.apuritansmind.com/puritan-favorites/jonathan-edwards/miscellaneous-writings/the-trinity/ 
Finally, it seems Sean is a little huffy that I call him a liar. Sean, you don't get kid gloves any more. You don't get the benefit of the doubt. I've bent over backwards to explain my view to you dozens of times, and if you still don't see fit to correctly represent it, I have no problem calling you out. If you want to use this as your excuse to exit this conversation - an exit which, I suspect, was and is forthcoming in any case - that doesn't bother me. My responses to you are no longer to convince you but to prevent you from doing spiritual and intellectual harm to others. Your allegiance to Clark is taking precedence to Scripture, whether you realize it or not. 

This particular discussion really is a microcosm of our months of discussion. Sean picks a topic. I respond. Sean switches topics. I point this out but respond anyway. This continues for a while, then Sean waits a few weeks and starts the process all over again. It's one charade after another. The difference is, I expect it now. It is perhaps for this reason that the conversation took a rather nasty turn after my last comment above. In my last blog post, I pointed out Sean's hypocrisy in moralizing on his blog while making backhanded remarks behind closed doors. As a close to this post, I hope readers will remember the following as just one more evidence of this (Sean's comments are indented, my replies are not):

You're losing it Ryan. Now you're threatening me? Do you really think I'm afraid of you? Like I've said before you are a very arrogant young man. A theologically blind one too. More concerning is that you sound like someone on the verge of a nervous breakdown. That's no joke. I don't think you're well. I mean, you're arguments to Patrick were so bizarre (I hope to blog on it soon) that I really started to fear for your mental health.  
My advice to you is get off the Internet for a couple of months and devote your time to studying the Scripture and prayer. Good advice for anyone really. In your case I would recommend mediating specifically on those passages of Scripture that affirm the equality of the Son to the Father. Maybe then with doubting Thomas you may one day call upon Jesus Christ as your Lord and God too. 
And, you're right, we really don't want people with an allegiance to Clark on a Clark list. 8-P 

Supposed threats and my mental health... well, at least these are new. But they are even less worthy of a response than your arguments, if that is possible.

I am serious Ryan. I don't think you're well.

I guess when all else fails, one is left with questioning his opponent's sanity to justify ignoring his arguments.